09-18-2008, 05:52 PM
I like the cover art:
http://tinyurl.com/4qzudm
That's about it. :-\
I began this novel around June, stopped reading about 1/4 way through and actually almost forgot about it! Earlier today I briefly considered picking it up again (after I'm finished with the current novel)...then figured *why*? I know myself, and if it's forgettable...forget it.
The characters, including the main, are haphazardly introduced. Even well into the story the characters (with two exceptions) are not well formed. It's a social peripheral jumble.
The story's lead female character finds herself surrounded by men, at the expedition. This too is awkwardly written. She's either feeling adrift in a little sea of men or she's isolated.
This novel has an entirely different tone to that of "Season of Evil," also by Elsie Lee...which I also didn't finish because imo that novel isn't a Gothic. "Season of Evil" is well written, but is not a Gothic; at least halfway into it I was still waiting for "gothicness."
I hope Ms. Lee's other works are more rewarding. I have 2 or 3 other novels of hers.
Anyway, "Barrow Sinister" gets 1 star on a scale of 1 - 5.
Hopefully I'm not selling the novel short. But my overall advice would be to skip it.
http://tinyurl.com/4qzudm
That's about it. :-\
I began this novel around June, stopped reading about 1/4 way through and actually almost forgot about it! Earlier today I briefly considered picking it up again (after I'm finished with the current novel)...then figured *why*? I know myself, and if it's forgettable...forget it.
The characters, including the main, are haphazardly introduced. Even well into the story the characters (with two exceptions) are not well formed. It's a social peripheral jumble.
The story's lead female character finds herself surrounded by men, at the expedition. This too is awkwardly written. She's either feeling adrift in a little sea of men or she's isolated.
This novel has an entirely different tone to that of "Season of Evil," also by Elsie Lee...which I also didn't finish because imo that novel isn't a Gothic. "Season of Evil" is well written, but is not a Gothic; at least halfway into it I was still waiting for "gothicness."
I hope Ms. Lee's other works are more rewarding. I have 2 or 3 other novels of hers.
Anyway, "Barrow Sinister" gets 1 star on a scale of 1 - 5.
Hopefully I'm not selling the novel short. But my overall advice would be to skip it.